MARKET REPORT
San Juan Islands Real Estate
Quarter 3, 2026 | Year-to-Date Through September 30
Executive Summary
Through the first nine months of 2026, San Juan County closed $275,711,582 in real estate volume across 240 transactions — a 4% gain in dollar volume on 5% fewer sales than the same period in 2025. San Juan Island, on its own, tells a softer story: $108,388,919 across 99 transactions, down 12% in volume and 16% in transactions year-over-year.
Subtracting the first-half figures reported in the Q2 report isolates the third quarter itself. In July through September, the county closed roughly $115.8 million across 117 transactions, and San Juan Island roughly $53.1 million across 46. The county's average Q3 sale price of about $989,000 sits well below the $1.30 million average of the first half, which means the unusually luxury-heavy mix that defined H1 eased through the summer.
The high end is still doing the work for the county. Ninety-two sales over $1M have closed countywide year-to-date, up from 82 at this point in 2025, while San Juan Island has seen 31 such sales versus 35 a year ago. Many of those high-end closings were on Orcas Island, which the source summary describes as continuing to carry the county.
Buyers continue to hold the advantage. Inventory is close to where it stood a year ago — 137 listings on San Juan Island and 349 countywide as of October 1 — but pending sales are lower, at 14 on San Juan Island versus 21 last October. Sellers are negotiating with more flexibility, buyers face little competition, and lenders are using rate buy-downs and adjustable-rate programs to keep deals moving.
San Juan County — Year-to-Date Snapshot
Metric (YTD thru Sep 30)
2026
2025
Change
Dollar Volume
$275,711,582
$263,924,570
+4%
Number of Transactions
240
250
-5%
Average Sale Price (calculated)
$1,148,798
$1,055,698
+9%
Sales Over $1M
92
82
+12%
Average sale price is calculated from the published volume and transaction counts. 2025 comparison figures are from the October 2025 Q3 summary.
San Juan Island — Year-to-Date Snapshot
Metric (YTD thru Sep 30)
2026
2025
Change
Dollar Volume
$108,388,919
$123,100,070
-12%
Number of Transactions
99
116
-16%*
Average Sale Price (calculated)
$1,094,838
$1,061,208
+3%
Sales Over $1M
31
35
-11%
*Percent changes in volume and transactions are as reported in the source. A direct calculation from the published 2025 transaction count (116) gives approximately -15% for transactions. Average sale price is calculated.
The Third Quarter on Its Own
The source publishes year-to-date totals, so the figures below are derived by subtracting H1 2026 (reported in July) from the nine-month totals. They isolate July 1 through September 30.
Area (Jul 1 – Sep 30)
Dollar Volume
Transactions
Avg Price
Share of Vol.
San Juan Island
$53,125,200
46
$1,154,896
45.9%
Orcas, Lopez, Shaw & Outer
$62,625,311
71
$882,047
54.1%
San Juan County
$115,750,511
117
$989,321
100%
Derived figures. 'Orcas, Lopez, Shaw & Outer' is the county total less San Juan Island; the source does not publish Orcas, Lopez, or Shaw individually for Q3.
Two patterns stand out. First, San Juan Island's Q3 average price of roughly $1.15 million was above its H1 average of $1,042,700, so the island's slower quarter came from fewer dollars, not lower prices. Second, the rest of the county closed 71 transactions in Q3 versus 46 on San Juan Island, so activity outside the island picked up materially after a first half in which the two areas were closer to even.
Against Q3 2025, the quarter was softer in dollars. Backing out approximate 2025 first-half figures from the published year-over-year changes suggests countywide Q3 volume was roughly 18% lower than a year earlier on a modestly higher number of closings, and San Juan Island volume roughly 20% lower. These comparisons rest on inferred 2025 figures and should be read as directional only.
Year-to-Date by Area
Area (YTD thru Sep 30)
Dollar Volume
Transactions
Avg Price
Share of Vol.
San Juan Island
$108,388,919
99
$1,094,838
39.3%
Orcas, Lopez, Shaw & Outer
$167,322,663
141
$1,186,686
60.7%
San Juan County
$275,711,582
240
$1,148,798
100%
Derived from published county and San Juan Island totals. Orcas Island alone closed $86.7M across 50 transactions in H1 2026 per the prior report; a nine-month Orcas figure was not published.
Market Conditions
The High-End Concentration
Countywide, 92 sales above $1M have closed so far this year compared with 82 in 2025, and 41 of them arrived in the third quarter (92 less the 51 reported at midyear). On San Juan Island the pattern runs the other way, with 31 sales over $1M against 35 last year. Together these explain much of the divergence: the county is up in dollars because of Orcas, while San Juan Island is down in both dollars and units.
Negotiation and Buyer Leverage
Simonson describes the transaction process as more drawn out than usual: instead of an offer, a counter, and a contract, deals are now commonly going through several rounds of counters from both sides before coming together. She notes that sellers are motivated and negotiating with authority, and that the spread between the discount off list price and the discount off original list price reflects price reductions needed to attract a buyer. The published negotiation averages are very similar to 2025, but the buyer pool is smaller.
Days on market are lower than in past years, which she attributes to sellers pricing closer to current market value. Her summary also cites Redfin data showing that nearly half of U.S. home sales in August included a seller concession such as a rate buy-down or help with closing costs, and notes that local lenders are offering creative rate buy-down and adjustable-rate programs that are helping some buyers proceed.
For reference, the most recent trailing-12-month San Juan Island figures confirmed in the Q2 report were an average of 6.1% below list price and 107 days on market across 118 home sales. The Q3 summary presents updated negotiation figures only as charts, which could not be read as text, so those Q2 figures are shown here as the last confirmed numbers rather than updated ones.
Inventory and Pending Sales
Inventory Snapshot
Jul 2, 2026
Oct 1, 2025
Oct 1, 2026
San Juan Island — Total
144
142
137
San Juan Island — Active
125
121
123
San Juan Island — Pending
19
21
14
County — Total
356
341
349
County — Active
308
298
313
County — Pending
48
43
36
Inventory has built steadily over the past year, with seasonal and holiday dips along the way. Total listings on San Juan Island (137) and in the county (349) are very close to last October, but pending sales are lower on both: 14 versus 21 on San Juan Island, and 36 versus 43 countywide. Similar listing counts with fewer contracts in hand points to slower absorption heading into the winter months.
Pricing
The Q3 summary did not republish the 12-month median home price. The last confirmed readings, as of June 30, 2026, were $795,000 for San Juan Island (unchanged year-over-year) and $930,000 for the county (up 10%). Calculated year-to-date average prices through September are $1,094,837 on San Juan Island and $1,148,798 countywide. Averages reflect the mix of what sold and are not a measure of appreciation.
What to Watch Heading Into Q4
- Pending sales. Lower pendings than a year ago suggest fewer closings in the coming quarter unless contract activity picks up.
- Orcas momentum. Whether Orcas high-end activity keeps carrying county volume will largely decide how the year finishes in dollars.
- Seller concessions and creative financing. Rate buy-downs and adjustable-rate programs are keeping some buyers in the market and are likely to remain a feature of negotiations.
- Seasonal slowdown. Fall and winter are typically the slower shoulder seasons locally, when sellers are also more open to contingent offers.
- Pricing discipline. With a smaller buyer pool, price reductions remain one of the few tools sellers have, and properties priced near current value are moving faster.
Outlook
For buyers, the conditions described through Q3 remain favorable: ample selection, little competition, flexible sellers, and negotiating authority at most price points. Buyers should be prepared for multiple rounds of counteroffers and can reasonably ask about concessions as well as price.
For sellers, the market rewards accurate pricing and strong preparation. Listings priced at current market value are selling faster than in prior years, and a seller who starts high should plan for reductions. With pending sales running below last year's pace, sellers listing now should expect a patient buyer pool.
Year-end results will depend heavily on the fourth quarter, which is seasonally quieter. As in the Q2 report, the source describes a market shaped by national and global economic conditions and interest rate uncertainty, so any forecast for the final quarter carries unusual uncertainty.
Sources & Methodology
Primary source: Merri Ann Simonson's San Juan Island and County Real Estate Market Summary, published October 15, 2026 by Coldwell Banker San Juan Islands, drawing on Northwest Multiple Listing Service (NWMLS) data for all brokerages. Year-to-date figures cover January 1 – September 30, 2026. Inventory snapshots are as of October 1, 2026 (current) and October 1, 2025 and July 2, 2026 (comparisons, from the prior summaries). First-half 2026 figures are from the July 16, 2026 summary.
Third-quarter-only figures, average sale prices, the 'Orcas, Lopez, Shaw & Outer' grouping, and the approximate Q3 2025 comparisons are calculated from the published figures and are not published by the source. The source itself cautions that its numbers are trend indicators for a small rural market (roughly 20 closings a month countywide) and should not substitute for a custom NWMLS search when pricing or valuing a specific property.
This report aggregates publicly reported market data and is provided for informational purposes only. It is not investment, tax, or legal advice. Individual property values may vary materially from market-wide medians and averages. Confirm any specific figures with a licensed local broker before transacting.
Owen Albert
Have questions about the market?
Every market report tells part of the story. A conversation fills in the rest.
Begin a Conversation